Mandy is GTA 6's most talked about NPC for more than one reason.

Some GTA 6 players have been less than impressed with Lucia's actions and have decided Mandy would be a better fit for Jason.

However, while Lucia may have her flaws, Mandy's potential dark secret might mean players will be better sticking with Lucia.

Jason's First Encounter With Mandy

Mandy turns up in Pipework, an early Chapter 1 story mission.

Brian sends Jason to collect her overdue rent, and she won't pay until somebody fixes her blocked kitchen sink. It looks like she has staged the emergency to get Jason over there.

Jason Duval lies under a kitchen sink fixing the pipes while a blonde woman in a leopard-print bikini and red slippers watches in GTA 6
Image credit: Beebom

From there it's a full-court press. She walks him to the bedroom instead of the kitchen, brings up their history, changes into a bikini and makes one last attempt to keep him there when he tries to leave.

At this point many GTA 6 players want to start a romance with Mandy ditching Lucia in the process.

Unfortunately for the Lucia haters that is simply something you cannot do. Jason and Lucia are stuck together.

You get the option to provoke and defuse Mandy after you are forced to reject her but [Jason (https://gta6intel.com/characters/jason-duval) turns her down on every route.

A Finger, a Grave and a Trunk Full of Bleach

The killer theory comes from what's lying around her property once the job is done.

Start with the sink: when Jason swaps out the P-trap, the object that falls out looks like a severed finger, and Mandy grabs it and disappears.

Then there's the backyard. If you walk into the backyard there is a newly covered-up, body-sized hole and a few tubs of acid for good measure.

There are also saws in the yard and what appears to be a newly dug grave.

The clues don't stop there as you can open the trunk of her green Sedan. It holds a cleaver, a bottle of bleach, duct tape, wire and shears.

Lucia Caminos looks into the open boot of a rusty pink classic car holding a skeleton, in a scrapyard in GTA 6
Image credit: MrBossFTW / YouTube

There are three more final details: a room in the house you can't enter, at least two names tattooed on her body and Mandy mopping up what appears to be blood if you visit her house.

The Case for a Killer

Taken one at a time, each clue has an excuse. Together, they're harder to explain away.

The question for Jason is: Does she seduce men to kill them or kill the ones that turn her down?

If it's the first, Jason's refusal on every route may be what keeps him alive. Rockstar has done this before. RDR2 left a trail of mutilated bodies that led Arthur to Edmund Lowry Jr., and nothing in the story ever pointed you there.

It Could Just Be a Sex Toy (Unlikely)

The object in the sink looks like a finger on first glance, and in truth it probably is, but it could pass for a pleasurable toy.

If that's what it is, Mandy didn't kill anyone. She blocked her own sink to get her ex over, which fits everything else she does in the mission.

A grave-sized hole next to acid is hard to explain, though.

This could remain as one of Rockstar's unsolved mysteries.

Returning to Mandy's House

In Chapter 3, players have the ability to return to Mandy's house. Doing so is rather uneventful though.

Mandy and Jason agree to remain friends and then you are unable to have any further dialogue with Mandy at that point.

You can also return to her at night (as mentioned above) where you will see Mandy mopping up red liquid on her bathroom floor.

So, in conclusion, unless a new way presents itself in the coming weeks, there is no way to romance Mandy in GTA 6.